Leah gets a phone call from Kyle just after midnight, expressing his worry because her home was empty and her car was gone.
She informs Kyle that she had gotten scared after he told her about James Finley, and decided to stay in a motel instead of her possibly dangerous home.
Kyle goes to visit Leah at the motel and they spend the night together.
The next day, while still at school, Leah hears murmurs and sees the students whispering. A car was being pulled out from the lake behind the Tavern.
It turns out it was Leah's missing car. Leaving everything behind at the school, she rushes to the scene.
As her car is being pulled from the lake, she notices a darker shadow in the front seat and it turns out to be the body of a man, not of Emmy as she was expecting.