Chapter Twenty-three: A Very Pessimistic Kind of Optimism

Contains spoilers

Overview

The narrator recalls Harmonee’s wartime trauma and her “pessimistic optimism,” paralleling Dad’s low-baseline philosophy. After a Covid-tracer call yields no specifics, Eugene is ordered to isolate for fourteen days, even from court. The family realizes John worked at Henry’s House on the exposure day, reframing assumptions about Adam’s whereabouts and company.

Summary

The narrator recalls interviewing Harmonee in Korea about the war, learning how fear and lived experience defied statistical “rarity.” Years later, Mom reveals the hidden truth: soldiers assaulted Harmonee and Aunt Chesuk; a bomb killed their family while the sisters survived because they were being raped. Harmonee’s dark, protective “pessimistic optimism” becomes a guiding theme.

Linking this to Dad’s low-baseline philosophy, the narrator pivots to the present: after a voicemail from the Virginia Covid Team about Eugene’s exposure, Shannon and Detective Janus—both with family hit hard by Covid—abruptly depart, spraying themselves as they go.

Mom spends minutes on the phone with the health department but learns nothing identifiable due to privacy laws: no name, time, location, or condition of the positive contact. Frustrated by a system that presumes the living yet withholds information, Mom notes the only actionable outcome: Eugene must isolate for fourteen days, even excused from court, with exceptions only for testing and medical care.

The narrator senses ominous trade-offs—a “monkey’s paw” reprieve—then reexamines the exposure source. Remembering that Eugene saw multiple therapists Saturday, the narrator realizes John worked at Henry’s House that day. John finds no tracer messages, but the connection prompts the narrator to pull over, concluding that if this inference is right, it could reshape their understanding of where Adam is, with whom, and why.

Who Appears

  • Narrator
    Remembers Harmonee’s trauma, links it to current crises, drives to testing, and deduces a Henry’s House connection to Eugene’s exposure.
  • Mom
    Calls the health department, confronts privacy barriers, confirms Eugene’s 14-day isolation, and previously revealed Harmonee’s true wartime story.
  • John
    Worked at Henry’s House on the exposure day; checks for tracer messages, triggering a new theory about Adam’s possible whereabouts.
  • Eugene
    Identified as a close contact; ordered to isolate for fourteen days, excused from court appearances.
  • Harmonee
    Grandmother; survivor of wartime assault and bombing; exemplifies a bleak, protective form of optimism.
  • Adam
    Missing father; potential ICU patient in theory; his low-baseline philosophy is echoed in the narrator’s reflections.
  • Virginia health department representative
    Provides no identifying details due to HIPAA; mandates Eugene’s isolation and confirms legal excusal from court.
  • Detective Janus
    Leaves quickly after hearing the tracer voicemail, wary due to family Covid history.
  • Shannon
    Also departs after the tracer voicemail, disinfecting everything because of personal Covid concerns.
  • Aunt Chesuk
    Harmonee’s younger sister; survived the assault while a bomb killed their family.
© 2025 SparknotesAI