Chapter Seventeen: Logic Chains Gone Wrong

Contains spoilers

Overview

Mia and John realize Detective Janus withheld a park video and that Eugene is a suspect. They crash the intake hearing, where the video shows Eugene injuring Adam and lunging at a bystander. Despite Mom’s plea and Shannon’s disability-based arguments, Officer Higashida orders Eugene into secure placement pending hearings.

Summary

Mia recalls how she and John once “mind-melded,” then the twins revive that rhythm to reconstruct a timeline: a neighbor gave Detective Janus the park video at 7:30 p.m., before Janus questioned the family, implying Janus was testing them and viewing Eugene as a suspect. Determined to intervene, they barge into the intake hearing.

On the Zoom screen, Officer Higashida asks about Mia’s injured ankle. Mia minimizes it, denying Eugene pushed her, but Janus cites John’s earlier statement suggesting the opposite. Mom backs Mia, dismissing the ankle as irrelevant and defending Eugene’s gentleness, as Shannon objects to Janus’s line of questioning.

Janus plays the neighbor’s video: an escalating meltdown where Adam restrains Eugene, who appears to claw at Adam’s face, then turns toward the filming witness. The sound and imagery unsettle everyone. Eugene, unusually affected by this video, rubs his eyes and mirrors the eye-squeeze motions shown, then composes himself with “calm hands,” refusing his iPad.

Concluding the aggression is ongoing, Officer Higashida allows the petition to proceed and orders secure placement. Mom erupts, warning Eugene won’t survive detention. Shannon argues Eugene is incompetent to stand trial and protected by Virginia’s new autism/ID defense, urging against incarceration; Mia is devastated by labels that feel dehumanizing.

Higashida holds firm. The family hugs Eugene as the call ends, while Eugene fixates on the waving flag screensaver. Mia wonders whether it’s kinder not to grasp the looming separation and wishes she could absorb his fear to shield him.

Who Appears

  • Mia
    Narrator; reconstructs Janus’s timeline, crashes the hearing, denies a push, and grapples with dehumanizing legal labels.
  • Eugene
    Nonspeaking brother; seen clawing at Adam in video, mirrors motions, refuses iPad, faces secure detention.
  • Officer Higashida
    Juvenile intake officer; questions Mia, reviews the video, and orders petition and secure placement.
  • Detective Janus
    Detective; withholds then plays the park video, challenges Mia’s account, argues Eugene is dangerous.
  • Mom
    Defends Eugene, disputes injury claims, and pleads emotionally against detention for her son.
  • Shannon
    Family lawyer; objects to the video, argues incompetence and new autism/ID defense, tries to steady Mom.
  • John
    Twin brother; mind-melds with Mia, previously told police about a push, falters under questioning.
  • Adam
    Missing father; appears in the video restraining Eugene and seems injured during the struggle.
© 2025 SparknotesAI